"I Played Twister with a Ghost" 💀 DeNizzle • Evil Idol 2025: Round 1 • Contestant # 24

"The Happy Man" 💀 Lillianne Hickle • Evil Idol 2025: Round 2 • Entry # 14

"Joe Made a Choice" Creepypasta 💀 Luis Bermudez • Evil Idol 2019: Round 1

"Raymond's Will" Creepypasta 💀 Benjamin James • Evil Idol 2019: Round 1

"The Soul Game" 💀 Alice Mellor • Evil Idol 2025: Round 2 • Entry # 6

"The Circuit" 💀 Brock Hayes • Evil Idol 2025: Round 2 • Entry # 13

"The Visitor" Creepypasta 💀 Luis Bermudez • Evil Idol 2019: Round 4

"The Seven Doors Challenge" 💀 DeNizzle • Evil Idol 2025: Round 2 • Entry # 20

"Tenement" Creepypasta 💀 Kristyn Mass • Evil Idol 2019: Round 2

"The Misfortune of an Unwanted Visitor" 💀 Patrick Roeland • Evil Idol 2025: Round 1 • Contestant #11

"Better Films" Creepypasta 💀 Danielle Hewitt • Evil Idol 2019: Round 2

"The Woods and the Goddess" Creepypasta 💀 Kristyn Mass • Evil Idol 2019: Round 4

"I Followed Her Home" Creepypasta 💀 Elijah Ramsey • Evil Idol 2020: Round 1

"The Truth Behind the Mandela Effect" Creepypasta 💀 Ryan Aiko • Evil Idol 2019: Round 1

"Knocking" by Steven Shorter • Adam Wooley (#13) • Evil Idol 2018: Round 1

"An Unexpected Magi" Creepypasta 💀 Sean "TFB" Tivenan • Evil Idol 2019: Round 2

"One Night Stand" Creepypasta 💀 Umar MC Rally • Evil Idol 2019: Round 2

"Plot Holes" Creepypasta 💀 Greg Louis • Evil Idol 2019: Round 1

"The Entity and the Lad" Creepypasta 💀 Spencer Brus • Evil Idol 2020: Round 1

"My Grandmother Left Behind Some Really Dark Secrets" 💀 Shara Prophet • Evil Idol 2019: Round 1

"Beyond the Veil" Creepypasta 💀 Alex Hill-Knight • Evil Idol 2019: Round 2

"The Cookie Jar" Creepypasta 💀 Annie Burke • Evil Idol 2020: Round 1

"Salt in the Dark River" Creepypasta 💀 Adam Rosenbloom • Evil Idol 2019: Round 2

"A Recipe for Happiness" by Rachele Bowman • Dayjan Lesmond (#22) • Evil Idol 2018: Round 2

"You Humans Are Terrifying" Creepypasta 💀 Adam Rosenbloom • Evil Idol 2019: Round 1