The Linda Pagano Cold Case (1974, Ohio) — A 17-Year-Old Vanished Without a Trace

The Colonial Parkway Murders — The Lover’s Lane Killings That Still Haunt Virginia

The Disappearance of Robin Abrams — Vanished After Accusing the Powerful

The Unsolved Murder of Amber Tuccaro — The Man on the Phone

The Abduction of Jacob Wetterling — Vanished on a Minnesota Road

The Murder of Meredith Emerson — Georgia’s Lost Hiker Mystery

The Disappearance of Amy Mihaljevic: The Gift That Was a Trap

The Murder of Cari Farver (Iowa, 2012)

The Murder of Meredith Kercher — Italy, 2007

The Murder of Janet Chandler — Michigan, 1979

The Disappearance of Lisa Irwin — Missouri’s Vanished Infant

The Murder of Christa Pike — Tennessee, 1995

The Murder of Nona Dirksmeyer: Secrets Inside a Small Arkansas Apartment

The Murder of Tina Isa — Missouri’s Chilling 1989 Home Recording Case

The Disappearance of Lynn Messer (Missouri)

The Murder of Alice Donovan (South Carolina)

The Disappearance of Sage Smith (Virginia)

The Servant Girl Annihilator (Texas’ First Serial Killer?)

The Murder of Heather Bogle (Ohio) — The DNA They Ignored

The St. Valentine’s Day Massacre (1929, Illinois) — Chicago’s Bloodiest Gangland Execution

The Disappearance of Crystal Rogers — Kentucky’s Darkest Secret

The Haleigh Cummings Disappearance | The Night a Child Vanished in Florida

The Kurt Sova Case — The Boy Who Vanished in Ohio

The Murder of Evelyn Colon — The 17-Year-Old Found Dismembered in Pennsylvania

The Alphabet Murders — The Children Taken in 1970s New York

The Case of the Gypsy Hill Killer — California’s Forgotten 1976 Murder Spree

The Case of the Allenstown Four — The Mystery Inside Bear Brook

The Disappearance of Amanda Kay Jones — 8 Months Pregnant and Gone Without a Trace

The CE4 Alien Abduction Allegations — The Pascagoula Encounter

The Fort Worth Trio Disappearance — Three Girls Who Vanished Without a Trace

The Disappearance of Barbara Cotton — Vanished on the Walk Home

The Murder of Margaret Martin — 1938, Pennsylvania

The Girl in the Chimney — The Death of Dr. Jacquelyn Kotarac

The Phantom Killer of Jennings — Eight Women, One Town, No Answers

The Haunting of the Villisca Axe House — Iowa’s Most Disturbing Cold Case

The Mysterious Death of Ellen Greenberg (2011, Pennsylvania)

The Ammons Haunting — The Case that Drew Police and Doctors into the Home

The Murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart — Alone in the House

The Gardner Museum Heist — Two Fake Cops, Thirteen Stolen Masterpieces

The Stranger in the Attic — The Denver Spider-Man

The Lights No One Could Explain — The Brown Mountain Phenomenon

Found Where They’d Already Looked — Alonzo Brooks

Tortured, Ransomed, Dead — Charles Morgan | The Lantern’s Tale

DNA Found — Justice Denied — Kathy Page

The Second Man Who Vanished — The Disappearance of Felipe Santos

She Didn’t Run Away — The Disappearance of Alissa Turney

The Tire Change That Turned Fatal — Tammy Zywicki

Tied, Naked, Dead — The Rebecca Zahau Mystery

The Murder of Denise Amber Lee — The 911 Calls That Failed Her

The Disappearance of Dulce Maria Alavez (2019) — Vanished From a Playground in Broad Daylight

The Murder of Sharon Tate (1969, California) | The Crime That Shattered Hollywood

The Death of Stacey Castor (2005, New York)

The Murder of Judith Barsi (1988, California)

The Death of Diane Schuler (2009, New York) — A Wrong-Way Drive with No Answers

The Vanishing of Aundria Bowman (1989, Michigan)

The Vanishing of Johnny Gosch (1982, Iowa) — The Paperboy Who Never Came Home

The Death of Darlie Routier (1996, Texas)

The Mysterious Death of Don Henry & Kevin Ives — Found on Railroad Tracks

The Death of Peggy Hettrick (1987, Colorado) A Murder, a Wrongful Conviction & a Killer Never Found

The Disappearance of Brad Bishop (1976, Maryland)