Welcome to Why It's Art! I don't know anything about art, but I want to understand why it's art. Sometimes I stand in front of a painting and ask myself: “Why is this art?” Join me on the journey to understand art better by uncovering the unique features and stories behind iconic works. Let's explore what makes certain artists legendary and why their creations are celebrated as masterpieces.


why it's art

In this dramatic scene from 1897 Edmund Blair Leighton takes us back to the 14th century. A desperate noble family has arrived at the water gate of a monastery. They carry heavy chests of gold and treasure but their wealth cannot save them now. The artist created this work during the 60th anniversary of Queen Victoria’s reign when stories of knights and chivalry were incredibly popular.

Leighton captures the precise moment of arrival. The adults in the boat stare anxiously at the elderly friar in the shadows. They are waiting for his permission to enter the sanctuary. However the young boy captures our attention the most. He looks fearfully over his shoulder which suggests their enemies are close behind.

A critic once observed that Leighton bridges the gap between legend and real life. He portrays people from the past with feelings that belong to our own time. We can feel their panic and the urgent need for safety. The gold in the boat means nothing if they cannot reach the shelter of the monastery walls.

Edmund Blair Leighton; In Time of Peril; 1897; Oil on canvas; 124.5 x 168.9 cm (49 x 66.5 in); Auckland Art Gallery Toi o Tāmaki; Auckland, New Zealand

1 day ago | [YT] | 42

why it's art

Imagine stepping into a busy Roman restaurant and suddenly freezing the room. This is the exact moment Carl Bloch captures in his masterpiece “In a Roman Osteria” from 1866. The painting breaks the fourth wall because the figures are reacting directly to you. The man in the center looks absolutely furious. He grips his fork with a clenched fist and has a knife tucked into his belt. We have to ask why he is so angry. Is he a jealous lover or perhaps a protective brother? It seems he hates that the women find you interesting.

The women react very differently. The lady on the left seems amused by your arrival while the woman on the right shoots you a flirtatious glance. This tension between danger and attraction is everywhere. Look at the table details. There are insects like bees or flies buzzing around the leftovers. Art historians note the phallic shape of the decanter near the woman on the left. It sits dangerously close to a sharp knife which hints at a mix of seduction and threat.

Even the cat in the bottom left corner stares directly into your soul. In the background you can actually see the artist Carl Bloch sitting with his back to us. He is talking to the man who commissioned this painting. This work is a brilliant genre painting that turns the viewer into the uninvited guest.

Carl Bloch; In a Roman Osteria; 1866; Oil on canvas; 148.5 x 177.5 cm (58.5 x 69.9 in); National Gallery of Denmark (Statens Museum for Kunst); Copenhagen, Denmark

3 days ago | [YT] | 81

why it's art

This painting tells one of the most heartbreaking stories in nineteenth century art. Painted by the French artist Hugues Merle it depicts a woman who seems lost in a world of her own. At first glance she appears to be a devoted mother nursing her child in a quiet outdoor setting. However a closer look reveals a tragic reality that changes everything.

The bundle in her arms is not a baby but a rough wooden log wrapped in rags. The title of the work gives us the sad context we need to understand the scene. The woman has lost her mind and likely her child. Her delusion allows her to care for this piece of wood as if her baby were still alive. Her haunted expression stares past us into a void of grief.

Merle was a master of French Academic art and was known for his ability to paint realistic textures and emotions. He uses shadow and light here to focus our eyes on her face and the wooden log. This painting is not just a portrait of madness but a study of deep human suffering. It asks us to look with empathy at those who have been broken by life.

Hugues Merle; The Lunatic (or The Madwoman of Étretat); 1871; Oil on canvas; 169.5 x 118.7 cm (66 3/4 x 46 3/4 in); Arnot Art Museum; Elmira, New York, USA

5 days ago | [YT] | 65

why it's art

This painting captures a scandalous moment from the year 1501 that looks like a scene from a dramatic film. It depicts Lucretia Borgia sitting on the papal throne while her father Pope Alexander VI is away. The artist Frank Cadogan Cowper traveled to the actual room in the Vatican to copy the wall decorations by Pinturicchio perfectly. He even painted the faces of the Cardinals based on their real historical portraits.

The details in this artwork tell a story of luxury and hidden sin. At the center a Franciscan friar bows low to kiss Lucretia’s shoe while two noblemen carefully pull back her dress. At the bottom of the throne a small monkey eats a piece of fruit which often symbolizes lust or the lower instincts of man. To the right a small bird walks on the carpet. In the shadows of the background you can see men wearing turbans who are likely foreign dignitaries witnessing this unusual court.

Cowper uses these details to create a heavy atmosphere. The sea of intense red robes surrounds the pale woman who sits calmly in charge. The painting is not just about history. It is about power and gender. It shows a woman taking control in a place dominated by men. It represents a clash between the holy setting of the church and the worldly power of the Borgia family.

Frank Cadogan Cowper; Lucretia Borgia Reigns in the Vatican in the Absence of Pope Alexander VI; 1908 to 1914; Oil on canvas; 231.1 x 156.2 cm (91 x 61.5 inches); Tate Britain; London, United Kingdom

1 week ago | [YT] | 56

why it's art

This intense painting by William Holman Hunt captures a heartbreaking moment from a famous play by William Shakespeare. The scene shows a brother named Claudio inside a dark prison cell. He has been sentenced to death. His sister Isabella visits him. She is dressed as a nun in white. The dramatic tension here is incredible because Claudio is asking his sister for the impossible. He wants her to sleep with a corrupt judge to save his life.

The symbols in the room tell their own tragic story. Fallen apple blossoms lie on the floor and on Claudio’s cloak. They represent the fleeting nature of youth and his fallen moral state. A lute hangs silently in the window. It is tied with a red ribbon and stands for the pleasures of life he can no longer touch. His rich belt and purse show his vanity. He clings to the material world while Isabella clings to her spiritual vows.

The contrast in the painting tells the whole story. Isabella stands upright and firm in her white habit. She represents purity and moral strength. Claudio slouches in the shadows and represents human weakness. Through the window you can see nature in full bloom. This bright view reminds us of the beautiful life Claudio is about to lose. It is a masterpiece that asks us what we would sacrifice to live.

William Holman Hunt; Claudio and Isabella; 1850; Oil on mahogany panel; 77.5 x 45.7 cm (30.5 x 18 in); Tate Britain; London, UK

1 week ago | [YT] | 40

why it's art

In this masterpiece, Vermeer invites us to be voyeurs. We stand in a darkened room, peering through a doorway into a brightly lit scene. It feels as though we are witnessing a private moment we were never meant to see.

A wealthy woman has been interrupted while playing her lute. She holds a letter in her right hand, which her maid has just delivered. The lady looks up with an expression that mixes anxiety and hope. Vermeer likely never gave this painting the title "The Love Letter" himself. That name came much later. However, he left us clues to confirm it is indeed about romance.

The seascape painting on the wall behind the women is a deliberate symbol. In the 17th century, love was often compared to the unpredictable, sometimes calm, but often stormy and dangerous sea. The broom and slippers in the foreground remind us that when love arrives, even the most mundane daily chores are cast aside. We will never know the message in that letter, but we can feel the tension it brings.

Johannes Vermeer; The Love Letter; ca. 1669 - ca. 1670; Oil on canvas; 44 cm × 38.5 cm (17.3 in × 15.2 in); Rijksmuseum; Amsterdam, Netherlands

1 week ago | [YT] | 59

why it's art

This painting captures a split second of pure horror. We see Orestes from Greek mythology who has just stabbed his own mother to avenge his father. The spirits of vengeance arrive even before her body hits the ground. Orestes covers his ears and twists his body in agony as three terrifying Furies swarm him with snakes and torches.

William-Adolphe Bouguereau created this dramatic masterpiece in 1862. This dark and violent subject was actually quite unusual for him. He was the grand master of the French art establishment but he was famous for painting gentle peasant girls and soft mythological beauties. Here he traded his usual peaceful style for raw energy and terror to show his incredible range as a painter.

The image freezes the moment when guilt overwhelms the killer. It shows us that while a physical act might take only a moment the emotional consequences strike instantly. The Furies are not just monsters but symbols of a conscience that will never let him rest.

William-Adolphe Bouguereau; Orestes Pursued by the Furies; 1862; Oil on canvas; 227 x 278 cm (89.4 x 109.4 in); Chrysler Museum of Art; Norfolk, USA

1 week ago | [YT] | 61

why it's art

This painting tells a story of broken appearances that draws heavily on French Naturalism. Similar to Henri Gervex’s famous painting Return from the Ball the scene depicts a couple who have just returned home from a social event. The festivities are over and the harsh reality of their relationship has taken over the room. The transition from public elegance to private misery is brutal and immediate.

The woman has collapsed on the sofa in tears still wearing her elegant gown. On the chair to the right we see her discarded evening wrap and feathered accessories thrown carelessly aside. This pile of luxury clothing represents the social mask she has just stripped off. The man sits nearby smoking a cigar with a look of cynical exhaustion rather than anger. He seems tired of the drama and ignores her pain completely.

On the floor lies a pink rose that likely fell from her dress or bouquet during the argument. This small detail serves as a sad symbol of their withered romance. Almeida uses this composition to criticize the hypocrisy of bourgeois marriage. They pretend to be happy in society but despise each other behind closed doors.

Belmiro de Almeida; Arrufos (Lovers’ quarrel); 1887; Oil on canvas; 89 x 116 cm (35 x 45.7 in); Museu Nacional de Belas Artes; Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

2 weeks ago | [YT] | 79

why it's art

This 1657 masterpiece by Nicolaes Maes is a classic example of the Dutch Golden Age. Maes was a talented student of Rembrandt who loved to hide stories within his domestic scenes. Here the mistress of the house pauses on the stairs and catches our eye with a quiet smile. She has found her maid neglecting her duties and wants us to share the moment with her.

The house is a web of secrets and consequences. In the hallway a bright red cloak belongs to a soldier who is distracting the maid. This small romance starts a chain of events that affects the entire home. Because the maid is busy the kitchen is left completely unguarded. This gives the family cat the perfect chance to jump on the table and steal the meal. Meanwhile the family waits on the upper floor for a dinner that is now lost.

Maes uses this clever scene to talk about order and the dangers of distraction. Each detail like the discarded coat or the stolen food helps build the story. The painting turns a simple household mistake into a grand theatrical performance. It asks us to consider how our own small choices impact others around us. In this house every open door reveals a new part of the drama.

Nicolaes Maes; The Eavesdropper; 1657; Oil on canvas; 92.5 x 122 cm (36.4 x 48 inches); Dordrechts Museum; Dordrecht, Netherlands

3 weeks ago | [YT] | 79

why it's art

Imagine being surrounded by your worst nightmares while trying to find peace. This haunting masterpiece by Jan Mandijn belongs to the Northern Renaissance movement. It draws heavy inspiration from the surreal world of Hieronymus Bosch. The painting shows Saint Anthony the Great as he retreats into the desert to pray. But instead of silence he finds a chaotic world filled with monsters and strange creatures.

The artist uses incredible detail to show the struggle between good and evil. While a city burns in the background and demons crawl from every corner the saint stays focused on his holy book. It is a powerful image of mental strength. Mandijn captures a moment where the physical world feels like a fever dream. The painting reminds us that true peace comes from within even when the world outside feels like it is falling apart.

This artwork is more than just a religious scene. It is a deep look into the human mind and our fears. The strange hybrid animals and mechanical monsters were meant to shock viewers in the sixteenth century. Today they still fascinate us with their creativity and darkness. In a world full of distractions can you stay as calm as the saint in the center of this storm?

Jan Mandijn; The Temptation of St. Anthony; 1525-1535; Oil on panel; 61.5 x 83.5 cm (24.2 x 32.8 inches); Frans Hals Museum; Haarlem, Netherlands

3 weeks ago | [YT] | 52