[Opinion] Season 9 Operates as a Spin-Off Within The X-Files
The ninth season of The X-Files was once one of television’s biggest taboos – rarely acknowledged, ultimately rejected by fans and critics alike. But under the circumstances, those reactions may have been extremely emotional and were potentially unfair. With the benefit of hindsight, a reassessment proves to be worthwhile. There are two major reasons for the fate of this installment. The most obvious is Mulder's absence in most of the episodes. The fandom saw him as the driving force behind the series – he was the reason the X-Files casework was resumed, as the mystery surrounding his sister led him to develop a big interest in the paranormal. The other reason is the season's status as the endpoint of the original run, given that the series did not conclude with Mulder and Scully on a general level (except for the feature-length finale).
While the ninth season preserves the series' thematic elements, it differs from the rest due to a drastic shift in character dynamics and an overall distinct feel. Its strikingly different title sequence is more than symbolic – it signals that the season operates like an independent entity while remaining part of the main series.
To understand how much of a wild card this season is in the grand scheme of things, let's look at how The X-Files series is figuratively divided:
• Original era
Seasons 1-5; Fight the Future film; Seasons 6-7: the Mulder–Scully relationship front and center; classic title sequence
• Sequel era
Season 8: a change in character dynamics with the introduction of Doggett, with various familiar elements linked to both Scully and Mulder; updated title sequence (classic and new elements)
• Spin-off era
Season 9: more change in character dynamics, with an ensemble cast featuring the Scully–Doggett–Reyes trio; revamped, modernized title sequence
• Revival era
I Want to Believe film; Seasons 10-11: a full reestablishment of the Mulder–Scully partnership; classic title sequence
Key aspects: • Perception versus actual content
Without context, the season's overwhelmingly negative reputation at the time may seem puzzling now. One indicator that suggests a preconceived bias against it is that roughly half of the individual episodes garnered a positive reception, which increases to more than two thirds when factoring in mixed-to-positive reviews.
• Variety in storytelling
While this season carries a significant degree of darkness reminiscent of the previous one, its style aligns more closely with the blend of horror and conceptual sci-fi/fantasy that defines the seventh season. Concept-driven episodes like "4-D" (parallel universes), "Audrey Pauley" (life–death limbo) and "Scary Monsters" (manifested imagination) exemplify the continued experimentation of the series. Dramatic pieces like "Release", "William" and "The Truth" evoke emotional intensity for the characters.
• Great production values
Despite its long run, the show still delivers visually at this stage. The production remains as polished as in previous seasons, with remarkable cinematography and art direction, such as in "John Doe".
• Feminine energy
The Scully–Doggett–Reyes trio is a novelty, but the intriguing part is the Scully–Reyes relationship. Two steadfast, independent, and distinct female characters who respect and support each other, which is refreshing and forward-thinking. "Improbable" is a fitting showcase of this dynamic.
• External factor
There is now an outside factor that did not exist back then: this is no longer the series' final installment, thanks to the second film and revival seasons, which may enhance its appeal. Instead of being an endpoint, it serves as a bridge between the past and the future.
Mulder's absence, fan disillusionment and the less prominent cultural presence of post-1990s The X-Files all played against Season 9 – overshadowed by the excellence that preceded it. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that the negativity that surrounded this installment, between its merits and shortcomings, stemmed more from a matter of context than the quality itself. It may surprise open-minded viewers. In an alternate reality, had it been the first season of a separate Dogget–Reyes spin-off, it might have found success.
The X-Files Forever
[Opinion] Season 9 Operates as a Spin-Off Within The X-Files
The ninth season of The X-Files was once one of television’s biggest taboos – rarely acknowledged, ultimately rejected by fans and critics alike. But under the circumstances, those reactions may have been extremely emotional and were potentially unfair. With the benefit of hindsight, a reassessment proves to be worthwhile.
There are two major reasons for the fate of this installment. The most obvious is Mulder's absence in most of the episodes. The fandom saw him as the driving force behind the series – he was the reason the X-Files casework was resumed, as the mystery surrounding his sister led him to develop a big interest in the paranormal. The other reason is the season's status as the endpoint of the original run, given that the series did not conclude with Mulder and Scully on a general level (except for the feature-length finale).
While the ninth season preserves the series' thematic elements, it differs from the rest due to a drastic shift in character dynamics and an overall distinct feel. Its strikingly different title sequence is more than symbolic – it signals that the season operates like an independent entity while remaining part of the main series.
To understand how much of a wild card this season is in the grand scheme of things, let's look at how The X-Files series is figuratively divided:
• Original era
Seasons 1-5; Fight the Future film; Seasons 6-7: the Mulder–Scully relationship front and center; classic title sequence
• Sequel era
Season 8: a change in character dynamics with the introduction of Doggett, with various familiar elements linked to both Scully and Mulder; updated title sequence (classic and new elements)
• Spin-off era
Season 9: more change in character dynamics, with an ensemble cast featuring the Scully–Doggett–Reyes trio; revamped, modernized title sequence
• Revival era
I Want to Believe film; Seasons 10-11: a full reestablishment of the Mulder–Scully partnership; classic title sequence
Key aspects:
• Perception versus actual content
Without context, the season's overwhelmingly negative reputation at the time may seem puzzling now. One indicator that suggests a preconceived bias against it is that roughly half of the individual episodes garnered a positive reception, which increases to more than two thirds when factoring in mixed-to-positive reviews.
• Variety in storytelling
While this season carries a significant degree of darkness reminiscent of the previous one, its style aligns more closely with the blend of horror and conceptual sci-fi/fantasy that defines the seventh season. Concept-driven episodes like "4-D" (parallel universes), "Audrey Pauley" (life–death limbo) and "Scary Monsters" (manifested imagination) exemplify the continued experimentation of the series. Dramatic pieces like "Release", "William" and "The Truth" evoke emotional intensity for the characters.
• Great production values
Despite its long run, the show still delivers visually at this stage. The production remains as polished as in previous seasons, with remarkable cinematography and art direction, such as in "John Doe".
• Feminine energy
The Scully–Doggett–Reyes trio is a novelty, but the intriguing part is the Scully–Reyes relationship. Two steadfast, independent, and distinct female characters who respect and support each other, which is refreshing and forward-thinking. "Improbable" is a fitting showcase of this dynamic.
• External factor
There is now an outside factor that did not exist back then: this is no longer the series' final installment, thanks to the second film and revival seasons, which may enhance its appeal. Instead of being an endpoint, it serves as a bridge between the past and the future.
Mulder's absence, fan disillusionment and the less prominent cultural presence of post-1990s The X-Files all played against Season 9 – overshadowed by the excellence that preceded it. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that the negativity that surrounded this installment, between its merits and shortcomings, stemmed more from a matter of context than the quality itself. It may surprise open-minded viewers. In an alternate reality, had it been the first season of a separate Dogget–Reyes spin-off, it might have found success.
6 months ago (edited) | [YT] | 207