Just to mention, Mace Windu beat Palpatine in his prime, a task which Yoda couldn't even do when Palpatine got burnt to a crisp. Mace definitely wins this. Edit: When it comes to dueling, Palpatine is in his prime. However, when it came to force abilities, Palpatine was in his prime during later times.
1 year ago (edited)
| 64
Obi wan fans try to understand that a character being your favourite doesn’t mean you should vote for them in every poll challenge (IMPOSSIBLE)
1 year ago
| 38
Mace beat Sidious in a duel. Meanwhile Yoda told Obi-Wan he wasn’t strong enough and to fight Anakin instead
1 year ago
| 6
Mace Windus form feeds off of his opponents dark side energy, meaning the more dark side energy they pour into their attack the stronger his form will become to match their strength. Obi wan does not use the dark side and since he perfected his defense form he would just widow Mace Windu down until he provided an opening.
1 year ago
| 7
Mace windu takes it with very high difficulty. I think he was the best jedi with a lightsaber, he has been tested. he stalemated talzin and beat sidious, fought maul and two super mandos, fought grievous in legends. yoda is his second because of old age enabling him to only use one form and we have never seen yoda in his prime either.
1 year ago (edited)
| 7
I think people are forgetting that Mace Windu took on Palpatine practically single-handedly and won. Yes, Obi Wan beat Vader, but that was when he had just turned into a Sith, and before he went through almost two decades of training as a Sith, and even then, it took him a LONG time to beat him. The only way I could see Obi Wan winning is if it were Old Obi Wan vs. Mace Windu, or if Palapatine acted weaker than he really was in ROTS so that Anakin would’ve turned to the dark side.
1 year ago
| 8
Mace is overall the better duelist and much stronger with the force. Despite Obi wan becoming more connected to the force by ANH it does not make him more powerful in direct combat. Still, Mace would struggle with Obi-Wans elite duelling skills but ultimately win
1 year ago
| 39
Everyone here is talking about Obi-Wan in ROTS as if that was his prime. Dude has far better feats AFTER the prequel era.
1 year ago
| 1
Do people not remember when George Lucas said that in A New Hope Ben Kenobi was in his prime as a Jedi and could’ve easily defeated Vader was not at his prime but he instead chose to become a force ghost to better help Luke
1 year ago
| 5
Thought: because if maces form only works on sith and not Jedi would it be just like Juyo . Thats what I’m not to sure of because then it be kinda like fighting a more stronger maul for obiwan
1 year ago (edited)
| 1
Obi-Wan is my favorite Jedi but Mace is stronger, Mace has an argument to beat Yoda imo
1 year ago
| 4
Mace wins in their era but Ben Kenobi is probably stronger. He was able to fight Vader well.
1 year ago
| 5
Prime Obi wan is as strong as Windu and as wise as Yoda.....the later part makes him defeat Windu
1 year ago
| 2
What’s the new Ben kenobi scaling? Mace slams ROTS kenobi any day
1 year ago
| 5
I think at this point it's safe to assume that whatever option on these polls is the least voted is the winner.
1 year ago
| 1
YEEEEE BOI I GET TO DO IT AGAIN Strength - Windu Speed - Windu Agility - Windu Combat Speed - Windu Travel Speed - Kenobi IQ - Kenobi Intelligence - Kenobi Battle IQ - Kenobi >= Mentality - Kenobi Planning - Kenobi Adaptability - Kenobi Durability - Windu Endurance - Windu Stamina - Windu Skill - Kenobi Dueling - Kenobi Force Power - Windu Force Abilities - Windu Force Combat - Windu Force Augmentation - Windu Force Potential - Windu Raw Power - Windu Force Mastery - Obi-Wan >= Force Knowledge - Obi-Wan AP - Windu DC - Windu Offense - Windu Defense - Obi-Wan Form Advantage - Kenobi Experience - Kenobi Battle Experience - Kenobi >= Feats - Kenobi Scaling - Kenobi Winner - Kenobi clutches v. high-extreme difficulty, at least in Canon
1 year ago (edited)
| 1
Star Cabal
Who Wins?
-Canon Primes
1 year ago | [YT] | 218