The Theorizer

Okay, I’ve had it. List every single unanswered question you still have about the show “Lost”.

1 month ago (edited) | [YT] | 1,419



@wohmanbetehrr5348

DID THE EVENTS OF LOST HAPPEN ON THE CURSED ISLAND OF MADAGASCAR!?!???

1 month ago | 241

@No-uc6fg

If the show is Lost then how did you find it?

1 month ago (edited) | 43

@AmiriBGaming

Alright, you asked for it. May Mort have mercy upon you... Was the entire timeline of Lost dictated by a paradox where the past, present, and future were simultaneously influencing each other? We know Lost plays with time travel, fate, and quantum entanglement, but what if the show’s entire narrative wasn’t just nonlinear—it was a self-sustaining time loop where cause and effect were constantly rewriting each other? For example: • The Incident in 1977 (where the bomb goes off) seemingly creates the very timeline that leads to Oceanic 815 crashing in 2004—yet the people who set it off were only there because the plane crashed in the first place. • The Man in Black needed a loophole to kill Jacob, but that loophole only existed because of events Jacob set in motion long before. • Desmond becomes “special” due to electromagnetic exposure, but what if he was always special and caused the events that led to his own importance? • The flash-sideways world seemed like an afterlife, but what if it was actually a future timeline so disconnected from reality that it bled into their past and dictated their choices subconsciously? If Lost operated under a quantum reality where time didn’t move forward or backward but collapsed in on itself, then every decision made was both predetermined and completely free—a paradox so complex that it could only be understood by something outside of time itself. So, the real question is: Did the characters ever actually have free will, or were they just caught in an infinitely looping reality where every outcome was already decided by events that hadn’t happened yet?

1 month ago | 34

@JLudwig-c4l

On a serious note there was weird episode in season 2 where Charlie gets weird visions. He ends up trying to baptise Aeron in this episode because of them. The show never explain's what this.

1 month ago (edited) | 68

@Cranberry38

why was walt special?

1 month ago | 1

@TheGivingBlob

Who was Hurley's girlfriend person (sorry I forgot their name) because there was a bunch of freaky stuff going on with her

1 month ago | 2

@JLudwig-c4l

What was the importance of Jack's tattoos

1 month ago (edited) | 23

@isickell8714

Did they ever find it?

1 month ago | 2

@anonymousanonymous6214

At what point, if any, do the separate timelines converge, and just how much of the island is the afterlife

1 month ago | 1

@kingofflames738

Is Mort involved in some convoluted, most out of left field, but totally believable within the possible explanations way? (I'm being serious, I would love it if somehow that's possible)

1 month ago (edited) | 8

@MCDreaddemon

Who made the time traveling island? Who made the giant Egyptian alagator-person statue? What's the smoke monster? of course lol

1 month ago | 2

@Bilgore_

Does lost take place in the same universe as Space Chimps

1 month ago | 27

@HannahRaeK

i’m hella curious about where the giant foot on the other side of the island came from

1 month ago | 3

@The777crash777

Is it Loss?

1 month ago | 2

@isaacsimpsonsflyingcircus9946

Why did Charlie unnecessarily sacrifice himself? If you rewatch the scene there was no need for him to close the door and drown

1 month ago | 25

@jimshoes

where did the island come from? what’s the origin story?

1 month ago | 1

@JBER_Eagle

What is the main characters name

1 month ago | 1

@vexen3669

Is Lost the prequel to Fortnite? 😦

1 month ago | 1

@JLudwig-c4l

This isn't exactly a mystery, but I think it's funny. So Ben knows that he has cancer and needs surgery. Fortunatly he has a great surgeon working for him Ethan. So what does Ben do? He sends Ethan to go on a risky infultration mission that ends up getting him killed. Great idea Ben

1 month ago | 16

@Tropical._.Depression

Arent we all truly lost.....

1 month ago | 1