The obvious answer is Bill. Just be respectful and nothing will happen.
2 days ago | 70
I feel like the people voting for Dutch don't realize that Dutch is completely batshit insane in RDR1. If he somehow, in his paranoia, thought you were going to betray him or tell the law his location, he would not hesitate to kill you.
1 day ago | 24
Easily Bill. Im a gay guy, so I wouldn't mind his attempt at flirting. Just so long as he doesnt have the gelding tongs!
1 day ago | 8
Dutch was absolutely insane in the first game. Bill was just lost and angry but he was still just the same bill from the second game.
32 minutes ago | 0
brotha, at 6:07 i open YouTube, vote bill, seen that it has 67% votes, open comments, and top comment have 67 likes. this is f*cked up.(lets do 67 likes)
6 hours ago | 0
Im like 3 times Sonnys size and a whole lot meaner ill be fine sitting in a room with a corpse.
1 day ago | 2
Bill or Bray. Bill is kinda chill and Bray wouldn't do shit if I hadn't had anything valuables on me.
2 days ago | 3
Obviously bill. Because I can always give him a book on how not to be dumb
2 days ago | 1
If I’m with Bill then me and him can just get really drunk and have a good time
10 minutes ago | 0
Bray's gonna eat me Sonny's gonna rword me Bill's gonna kiss me rdr1 Dutch would just go on a bloodlust cuz I'm not part of his gang Soo I can't decide which one's worst
2 days ago
| 8
Plaguezk
Who would you rather be stuck with in a locked room?
2 days ago | [YT] | 64