Video take-down: Study Analysis: GLP-1RAs on Weight Loss
Hello - If you aren't aware, under all my videos I have a 'Critique my Work' link so people can point out where I've made mistakes. Recently, someone (Dr. Mills) wrote in that one of the meta-analyses I covered in my GLP1RA study analysis had far more flaws in it than I presented. After a lengthy discussion with them, it seemed clear that the meta-analysis had more flaws in it than justifiable for a simple 'Amendment' under the video. As such, I've taken the video down.
Ultimately, the conclusion of the video likely stands (i.e. GLP1RAs cause weight loss), even in the face of this poor data, but it's still better to take down the video than keep it up with the assumption the data presented was high quality (because the end result isn't all that matters - learning how we get to that conclusion is also extremely valuable). Anyway, I'm thrilled to have had the opportunity to learn from an expert in meta-analysis like Dr. Mills, and expect to continue to improve to make sure I don't miss any other flaws in these types of studies.
Anyway, thank you to Dr. Kerry Mills for the corrections, and I hope you all have a great day.
Physionic
Video take-down:
Study Analysis: GLP-1RAs on Weight Loss
Hello - If you aren't aware, under all my videos I have a 'Critique my Work' link so people can point out where I've made mistakes. Recently, someone (Dr. Mills) wrote in that one of the meta-analyses I covered in my GLP1RA study analysis had far more flaws in it than I presented. After a lengthy discussion with them, it seemed clear that the meta-analysis had more flaws in it than justifiable for a simple 'Amendment' under the video. As such, I've taken the video down.
Ultimately, the conclusion of the video likely stands (i.e. GLP1RAs cause weight loss), even in the face of this poor data, but it's still better to take down the video than keep it up with the assumption the data presented was high quality (because the end result isn't all that matters - learning how we get to that conclusion is also extremely valuable). Anyway, I'm thrilled to have had the opportunity to learn from an expert in meta-analysis like Dr. Mills, and expect to continue to improve to make sure I don't miss any other flaws in these types of studies.
Anyway, thank you to Dr. Kerry Mills for the corrections, and I hope you all have a great day.
Nic
1 year ago | [YT] | 1,249