today will forever be known as the day this poll ALMOST had Captain Jack Sparrow!
1 week ago | 676
There's only one man who could be the best captain of a pirate crew- Captain Jack Sparrow!
1 week ago (edited) | 698
Hook has kept his crew together for, I assume, centuries. That's got to be worth some points.
1 week ago | 248
Two of these are already pirate captains.
1 week ago (edited) | 440
Hook actually succeeds in most of his endeavors. Look at his treasures in his cabins. He also provides not just a ship but a town and recreation for his crew. He even destroyed the Lost Boys TreeHouse and killed Rufio. It took Peter Pan to defeat him. He had loyalty of of a crew that cheered for him.
1 week ago | 43
Luffy saved a girl that was in the slave trade ever since she was 6, I think he's the clear winner XD
6 days ago | 1
I’d follow Monkey D. Luffy to the ends of the world. Time to set sail for the Grand Line!
1 week ago | 1
Luffy is the only person with a larger appetite than me, so we’d get along the best lol
1 week ago | 1
Why did it take seeing him next to Captain Hook on this pole for me to realize Luffy it’s more a kin to Peter Pan and actual pirates.
1 week ago | 1
Moana has the experience of both sailing and spent her childhood learning how to be a good leader. Hook may centuries of experience but his ship has mostly been docked in Neverland for that time, not sure if he could still handle the open sea. Flynn doesn't have any sailing experience as far as I'm aware but he was a professional thief. There are video compilations of the multiple times Luffy has tried to kill his own crew. Think I'll go with Moana on this one. 🤣
1 week ago | 25
Luffy found the most dysfunctional gaggle of crash out teenagers one by one, healed their trauma, and proceeded to create arguably the most successful and dangerous pirate crews in his entire world. The SHP literally threaten the World Government just by existing. One of them has knowledge that could bring the World Government crumbling down just by being made public, and another has memorized the blueprints to an ancient superweapon that could destabilize the world with its power. And yet HE'S still their captain. And the crew would follow him barefoot backwards into hell if he wanted to go there. It's Luffy.
1 week ago | 1
The actual pirate captain. Luffy all the way. I know Hook is too but he’s incompetant
1 week ago | 1
Luffy may be an idiot, but his crew respects him because hes a good captain and follow him til the end because of it
1 week ago | 131
I would say the luffy is a good person but a terrible pirate out of over a thousand episodes I think you can count the number of times he actually found any pirate treasure on one hand
1 week ago | 1
Eugene Animated
Who Would Make the Best Captain of a Pirate Crew? 🏴☠️
1 week ago | [YT] | 2,688