so uhh heres a theory about what might happen to Pencil. at the end of TPOT 19, Pencil makes a deal with One to go back in time and re-do everything so that she can fix all the mistakes she made with her friends. What if she gets stuck in a time loop. What if she gains the ability to go back and redo things, but she just can't stop doing it. Every time she makes like, a small mistake, or her friends notice she's acting weird, she freaks out, like "omg they hate me again i have to go back and fix it". and the more she does it the more natural it becomes until it's basically an involuntary reflex. idk i feel like it would fit her
3 days ago (edited) | 7
Theory: The Earth is a moon of Saturn along with other moons and Saturn being in a trojan orbit with The Really Weird Planet In The Orion Nebula along with other planets, just that they orbit normaly. Another Theory: One did not make Barf Bag, Basketball and Gaty non-existant, but actualy sent them to One’s realm/wasteland.
2 days ago (edited) | 5
The leafy detector made leafy and evil leafy 2 separate entities.
3 days ago | 15
Roboty may genuinely have extreme importance to the whole TPOT Plot from this point forward I feel like they're either going to save the whole universe in some way or maybe join 1's side due to how he's been treated Either that or I've gone crackpot
3 days ago | 5
Early tl;dr- Four trapped the EXITors since they're his idols, implied by X in BFB 30 The EXIT theory: Four made the EXIT as an excuse to have the BFDI characters all to himself. (besides the final 2/3 he was planning) Four was a big fan of BFDI, so he wanted to have his idols close to him. This theory explains a lot of things: 1. Why he gave up on taking Spongy and Loser back to the EXIT- He knew Spongy couldn't fit, and Loser was crafty enough to escape. Too risky. 2. Why he sent Balloony (and several other post-splitters) to the BRB- He lied about the EXIT being full. Balloony won the BFB 1 challenge for BEEP by deflating himself and launching himself into the air. He could escape the EXIT easily. 3. Why he isn't angry at the former EXITors anymore- He tried giving Roboty a fraction of Two's power, thinking Roboty had no hard feelings. He gave a fraction to Pencil and Liy for the same reason, and he tried to reason with Pencil even after she stole his powers. He also let Loser see how his former teammates and Winner were doing, and showed no hard feelings towards Leafy after her rejoin.
2 days ago | 1
A simple one i haven't seen anyone talked about: the unnamed and unknown creature in one of the doors in TPOT 11 is the same entity that terrorised GB in flashback in IDFB 1
3 days ago (edited) | 4
Porfily actually brainwashed the cast to believe they were part of the show all along
3 days ago | 2
My theory relates to Nonexisty: After the events of X Finds Out His Value, One and Three (who make the unlucky 13 when together) wanted to seek revenge since X was equal to 7, the lucky number. So they wanted to become the two most powerful Algebraliens of them all. Later on, when the sentient objects were first around, there was one called Peanut Butter, who One and Three saw as an easy target, so they decided to make him nonexistent in an attempt to gain power, banishing him out of the timeline and into a dimension of nonexistent entities. (This explains why Firey asked if he tasted peanut butter in BFDI 12) Four caught wind of this, and decided to use his powers to trap One in the moon and Three in that jail cell we saw in TPOT 11 so that they'll not cause any trouble again. Then, as we know, after One got freed in TPOT 9 thanks to Lightning's actions in TPOT 7, she began making contestants sign contracts so she can gain more power, and later on wipe more people from existence, namely Gaty, Barf Bag, and Basketball. So I have a feeling those wiped contestants got sent to that dimension where Nonexisty's true self, AKA Peanut Butter, is at. And I also predict that One will reluctantly bring back everyone she erased, including Peanut Butter, upon defeat. But, hey! That's just a theory, a BFDI theory!
3 days ago (edited) | 2
So basically this is how it is. Bfdia 5 ended. And after that bfdia 6. But here is the thing. if u saw the bfdia 6 deleted scenes video. They are nothing like bfdia 6 that came out. And focus on pencil and freesmart interactions. In the deleted scenes ok. Rn remember tpot 19. When one offered pencil to send her back to the past and fix her relationship with her alliance. so my theory is like this. One sent pencil back after bfdia 5. Which in bfdia 6-7. The ep where rocky gets out. Cuz in tpot when he got out. They said that amount of votes is the most he got. But it is bigger in bfdia. So how would that fit? If it didn't even happen. Next. Don't u see how pencil treats her alliance and friends in bfdia? She treats them the best in bfdia. Not any other season bro. She doesn't want them to leave her again. But it is one that sent her. And one won't just do something like that without receiving something in return. And what a certain item in bfdia. That one would want. Right. The yoylight. U saw how one got obsessed over only 1. Imagine if she got hold of that mineshaft. Bruh. So what I think is. One sent pencil back to the days of bfdia. so she can get hold of the yoylight. Now u can say the mineshaft got destroyed. But let's be fr. The one that ruby got came from space. But we were shown there are some yoylight underground. So it is possible to mine for more. Like Minecraft lol. Another point is dream island. We know that somehow dream island got destroyed and its remind stayed under the goiky canal. And last ep we were shown it got crushed. just to be a fake thing, and the real island is still with leafy somewhere. But we know that some sort of an event will happen leading to it being destroyed left under the canal. The pin and leafy interaction in bfdia. They look like they hate each other. But underneath they fixed their relationship and they are cool. In bfb we get total opposite. Like pin is still unsure about leafy. And coiny is the one trusting her. It is a bit odd. Now I can say that there are a lot of other stuff that could counter this theory. Like a lot. And sure with u on them. Like the ice cream episode that was shown in the timeline shifts. But at the same time. It still holds. And it might solve the confusion that is idfb and how a lot of ppl think it should be remade to make sense with everything else. In general I am in the middle. Until bfdia ends. I won't make decisions. This is just a fun lil thing that I made up based on my beliefs that's all. If read this whole entire thing then thx u. I hope u have a good day :D
3 days ago | 5
Nonexisty was One's first victim. He was a PB jar or peanut butter but he got erased by One. That's probably the reason why One got trapped in the moon
3 days ago | 6
If u rewatch the scene when one sends pencil back in the past. The camera moves a lil bit towards where she was standing and we see some remainings. And If u focus a bit towards the left u will see some lines make the shape of a 4. And they said, and quote me if I am wrong, that they left a hint to where one took 4. So I believe that one did indeed take him somewhere in her room. But just his body. His consciousness is in himself. Aka one sent 4 inside of himself and took his body away. This is just a lil theory and it may not be true lol. If u read this, ur cool
3 days ago | 3
Eraser has hallucinations, as he had in BFDI 25, thinking Leafy was a football, and BFDIA 1, thinking the eliminated contestants must be killed. But for some reason then it stopped...
3 days ago | 3
I think that X finds out his value IS canon his value only changed a few hours after X finds out his value (basically what I'm saying is every few hours X's value changes)
3 days ago | 2
1. Barf bag has a walking disorder bc she’s always sitting/leaning on things 2. The first season of BFDI was a social experiment done by the speaker boxes
2 days ago | 2
i have had this theory since bfdia 6 released and it’s about the full show having already happened but being released later because of idfb being after bfdia 6 but still saying that bfdia 6 isn’t supposed to be watched yet so tpot 20 and the entirety of bfdia probably already happened but we just can’t watch them
2 hours ago | 0
I have a feeling that the reason that one got locked up in the moon was because she erased someone then. And the other algebraliens didn’t like that, so they trapped her in the moon as revenge. And the person that she deleted is now known as nonexisty It could be 12 or 13 that got deleted because 12 and 13 are not present, one of them, or both, could have been erased. I hope this is true, that would actually be cool.
3 days ago | 1
two is working with the announcer. announcer wanted bfb to end sooner, two helped with this. I think he might show up in late tpot to do the same thing he did in bfb
3 days ago | 0
What if one actually did all those crimes to prevent a disaster from happening and she was imprisoned cause everyone thought she's crazy,the disaster that she foresaw was going to end everything and all living being in the universe. Also if you're wondering what abt what happened in tpot 15,she actually intended if gaty didn't sign at all she would return everything kinda to normal but still heavily gliched cause she doesn't have enough power to return things completely to how they were. Anyways it's your choose to think one is a villain or an anti-hero.
3 days ago | 1
Ok so here’s my theory on One’s origin: During the qna section of the BFDI x II vidcon panel, a fan asked if Three and One would work together. They didn’t reveal much, but apparently, if One and Three are together, they are in a bitter mood because the number thirteen is an unlucky number. (1 and 3, 13). If society could tolerate the number 13, they might be able to hang out again. Now, the number 13 is an unlucky number is many religions, and they are a variety of reasons why. But whatever the reason, something must have happened to the other Algebraliens to make them fear the number 13. Because One and Three always hung out, they decided to separate them. Then, One found them Yoylite and got revenge. This is likely how all the other Algebraliens got their powers. But One likely separated all the Algebraliens somewhere on that one Algebralien planet from TPOT 15. After that, the only remaining Algebraliens would be One, Two, Three, Four, X, and Six. One would be locked up in the moon, Three would be locked in the exit, Four would keep Six in the equation playground to protect him, Two likely goes into hiding somewhere else, and Four and X stick together. This also explains why Four kept the exitors locked up for so long. Because he didn’t want them accidentally busting Three out. Also, I think Two and One worked together for a brief period, because One refers to Two as “an old friend.” But seeing Two befriend Four and X would make One more vengeful, so she tries to steal Two’s power for revenge. So yeah, that’s my theory. Hopefully it comes true!
1 day ago | 0
Fourtle
Hello everyone!
So i was thinking of making a video where all of you would take the spot light instead of me, and i came up with this:
What are yall's best BFDI theories? any topic, any season, just a theory that YOU thought of and want to share!
I will be taking some of the best theories i see in the comments under this post and make a video about them, obviously you'd be credited for your theory if it makes it's way into the video!
If you think anyone's theory is good, give it a like so i can see it easily, More likes doesn't mean it will be in the video the theory has to be good and unique (and also you can post as many theories as you like, but try to keep each in different comments of yours, otherwise i may not consider taking it)
3 days ago | [YT] | 101