Thomas Mulligan

Who deserved to own the meteorite?

1 month ago | [YT] | 1,342



@CultTac

If Birdie owns it then Ann can sue for assault!

1 month ago | 615

@hey_thatsmyname

It's wildly entitled to claim that something that has entered into a house you are renting out to someone else is now yours.

1 month ago | 540

@SuperMortiki

Me, because I appreciate it more

1 month ago | 157

@hyabott5452

I feel like if you get hit by a 100 million year old rock that came from across the solar system you should get to keep it

1 month ago | 244

@Weeb148

We need @LawByMike with this one🗣🔥

1 month ago (edited) | 76

@DrFunkman

Pretty sure it’s legally Ann’s. Birdie may own the property, but Ann legally has possession of it, meaning that if something’s in the apartment, it is the property of Ann

1 month ago | 89

@R3dsl0th

Can someone explain what this is about?

1 month ago | 3

@therationalanarchist

I would have allowed Birdie to claim ownership and then Ann should have sued Birdie because the meteorite hit her. It's her property, she is responsible for the damages it caused.

1 month ago | 29

@IG12-ci8ri

Neither of them own it. Thats meteoritism

1 month ago | 53

@kidwasabi9633

she's a LIVING part of the impact crater bro cmon, is this even a question?

1 month ago | 2

@CaptainCamellot

Let's hope that the true owners don't come here looking for it.

1 month ago | 12

@danaleanne38

You don't choose the meteor, the meteor chooses you. 🤪

1 month ago | 4

@LiterallyGetoSuguru

It chose Ann. It is their destiny.

1 month ago | 2

@Twattleing

In baseball whoever catches it keeps it

1 month ago | 6

@grrr2049

By everyone's argument of "if it hit you, you should keep it." Then when someone stabs or shoots or even punches you(you are getting hurt),then you own that knife or gun or that person. It makes no sense

1 month ago | 7

@IndigoMaxwell341

I don’t understand this

1 month ago | 3

@rock_guyguy9591

lol idk what this is but I picked birdie because it sounds funny

1 month ago | 3

@utfhgioulk

If someone throws a bar of gold through the window it's not the house owners property

1 month ago | 1

@HumanBeing-h1l

I mean, legally speaking, I'd have to guess the person who would get to own the meteor is the person whose property line had said meteor fall on it. Since the meteorite was previously without ownership, and the state (or federal) government was willing (assuming the meteorite didn't contain something very valuable the state government would want) then the person whose property was either damaged or impacted by the meteorite would get to keep it. Because, using an analogy as an example, if I get hit by a car, it doesn't mean I magically now own that car. This is, of course, including the idea that the car is owned by nobody.

1 month ago | 19

@thekingadam51

Joe dirt. It was his space rock and space peanut.

1 month ago | 0