Invidious

Both are the best written characters with the most badass scenes it's too underrated in my opinion

1 month ago | 10

I feel like they both were written how they should have been. We didn’t want to lose John but his past caught up to him and no matter how many dead shots you get off you cant escape. Arthur had an expiration date but he used it for his redemption at the end and was the more peaceful sad ending.

1 month ago | 7

@devoncaban7403

RdR y’all really forgot how much of a badass John is

1 month ago | 1

@TheMasterReaper

Better-written? Arthur More badass? John imo

1 month ago | 1

@Weegeedood

Charecter wise, Arthur Better written as a cowboy, John.

1 month ago | 13

@raulbetancourt5795

Tough, both really deep written.

1 month ago | 0

@Tales_of_the_Bardbarian

It’s the difference between an A and an A+, but the difference is still distinct, as the results convey

1 month ago | 3

@Milkthrow

I always felt John's story was the more of the typical "Man wants to protect wife and child" story. Arthur's introspective journey as a dying man trying to do better was way more compelling. Really putting the "Redemption" in the game's title to good use.

1 month ago | 1