I just now saw this video, but 2 things strike me that might dissuade a click: 1. Subject clarity - I can't really tell what the Felyne looks like, and because I don't play MH Wilds, I don't see anything worth getting excited for. If you had a clear cutout of the design like a render from the wiki or something, I'd see the design, choose if it's interesting or not, and then click to see what Aki, Ina, and Aru Bro thought it was interesting. 2. Subject choice - I'll be real, a reaction to an outfit doesn't APPEAR to be worthy of a reaction compilation on the surface. Most reaction comps are to things that elicit pretty BIG reactions. Perhaps something about this DOES get that big reaction, but the thumbnail doesn't really communicate that if so. If there is a big reaction, it's probably best to focus on that member, include a quote in the thumbnail, and have multiple Holomembers in the background to visually imply a compilation! Sorry for the wall of text! Hope this was helpful in some part!
8 months ago | 4
For me personally it was recommended but I did not click because of two things. Yes the length but also I did not find the subject interesting enough for that video length. Personally I’ve had my own reaction while playing, my friend’s reaction, my favorite MH content creator’s reaction, and Ina’s reaction. I’ll probably watch it later.
8 months ago | 7
My notifications are working fine, and the video did appear on my recommendations. I don't like reaction videos in general. Wilds is a nice game, but I'm not into it that much either, other than watching gameplay of my favorite Holo members. I think the topic wasn't very interesting (silly costumes for cats are very common in MH games), even though some of the reactions were very funny (I just watched the video because of your post). The other compilation? Way more interesting, since it showed actual gameplay of how players of different skill and experience faced a new threat, how they coped, their obliviousness, and so on. I think compilations are more worth the effort if done around more key moments of the game, instead of mundane or "slice of life" kinda things. At the end of the day, Holomems are great to come up with funny things to say, but that alone doesn't mean everything deserves to be clipped. Sorry for the long essay, I hope it can be of help.
8 months ago | 2
Personally im just not interested in it cuz i havent played monster hunter im sure if i did i would definitely watch
8 months ago | 1
Apologies, I have seen it on my sub feed, but I have been trying to avoid watching anything MH related as I myself am not very far in the game. Sorry I don't have too much to suggest, but maybe you can break these compilations into groups? Like rather than the entirety of Holo pro, maybe group up all of Holo EN+ID (live and stars, and ID since there aren't too to many ID members compared to other branches) and do all of Holo JP+re gloss in another group. Not sure if this will do any good, but I'll be sure to edit this comment if anything else comes to mind, as well as watch any other clips I've missed (Need to watch some of the recent RoberuNightNea Split fiction playthrough.)
8 months ago | 0
i usually just watch what appears in my recommends algorithm, cant recall this one doing so despite most of yours do. Might be because i haven't kept an eye on monhun stuff, since it doesnt interest me much. (might be fun to play, but not my type of stream content). it might be flooded as well, there was tons of Monhun stuff earlier, but while i still see notices of people playing it, the amount of clips or monhun from outside "my streamers" has drastically dropped, it might be an overall that the algorithm has decided that the trend is dropping and thus is sending less people its way.
8 months ago | 0
i actually clicked on this and partly watched the first part then skipped to the holostars part, sorry. if i had to guess, they probably thought they've already seen it. the thumbnails is kinda similar to your previous holopro monhun compilation. cause i'll be honest i also almost skipped this but only watched it because i saw it was a new upload when this appeared on my dash.
8 months ago | 1
Oboretai Writing ch.
Asking for feedback.
The Compilation clip of Holopro members reacting to Felyne Nu Udra has been underperforming and I'm curious to why. I understand that longer clips can take longer to grow because clip watchers don't usually have 20 min to burn on a whim to begin with, but because a 23 min clip also took so much work and days to make, it's kinda disheartening to see it failing to reach as many people as I expected.
MHWilds as a game is still hot, especially with the recent title update, the Holomems are still playing it, and the Jin Hadad ult compilation clip of the same length has almost thrice the views of the Felyne Nu Udra one, so I really have no idea why this one is performing so badly.
Are my clips not showing up on your recommend? Is there something wrong with the title or thumbnail? If you have any ideas, feel free to suggest it. I'd love to make more MHWilds compilation, so I'd like to be sure the next one won't also just go under the radar.
https://youtu.be/ZiSiSem0Ar4
8 months ago | [YT] | 52