The Atlantic

The political scientist Charles Murray claimed that, by 2025, the genetics of intelligence would be basically understood. We are still far from achieving that goal, the psychologist Eric Turkheimer writes. theatln.tc/avNxlpdi

Murray co-wrote “The Bell Curve” in 1994, when “scientists’ best understanding of how genetics influenced human behavior was based on differences and similarities among family members, especially twins,” Turkheimer writes. The authors took the position that a person’s intelligence is substantially determined by genetics. “Most controversially,” Turkheimer continues, the authors “entertain the possibility that socioeconomic and educational differences among racial groups could be explained by differences in their IQ scores, and that these differences are at least partially attributable to genetic differences among the groups.”

After Murray doubled down on his old arguments in 2017 and Turkheimer opposed them, the two bet on whether we would basically understand IQ genetically by 2025. But today, “we do not remotely understand what Murray hoped we would,” Turkheimer argues.

The genetic or brain mechanisms that cause some people to be more intelligent than others remain unknown. “The more we have learned about the specifics of DNA associated with intelligence, the further away that goal has receded,” Turkheimer writes.

🎨: Akshita Chandra / The Atlantic

1 week ago | [YT] | 257



@captaincarl1

It's a general heritability. Not causative determinism. So the underlying assumption here is bunk.

1 week ago | 9

@williamhenderson1521

Racists like Murray were always big fans eugenics.

6 days ago | 4

@nilesoien7867

The Trump administration is making great strides in revealing the genetics of stupid, though

6 days ago | 15

@sparrowdrone

He knows perfectly well education has more to do with intelligence than genetics does and he knew it seven years ago too, but in the last seven years he has built himself a brand confirming popular prejudices because that’s easier than educating

6 days ago (edited) | 11

@RalfBernhard-g1c

Most people lack cognitive intelligence. Therefore the fact that ideologues and propagandists for US/Western hegemony over the globe, focus so much attention on "IQ" as determining factor in "Why the USA/collective West came to rule the world." The empire wants to avoid critical thinking, a core aspect of cognitive intelligence.

6 days ago | 3

@deadtoadsoup

Most people have about the same intelligence genetically, we are much more alike than different no matter where on the planet one is born. genetic intelligence has nothing to do with skin color or the amount of nose hair or the thickness of toe nails. However, environment is incredibly important including nutrition, exercise, and children who are read to at an early age and begin reading early. reading. lol darn I'm old...

6 days ago | 0

@Just-provide-the-files

We need to know the genetics of stupidity.

6 days ago | 1

@captaincarl1

He controls for socioeconomics in his data.

1 week ago | 2

@ProfessorBraus

Wait, wait, education matters??? 😅

5 days ago | 0

@sameagletheregal8526

The Atlantic swings and misses again.

6 days ago | 1

@JUSBURSELF

Autism moms what say ye?

1 week ago | 0