The duel where Anakin had his limb cut off by a Jedi.
2 weeks ago (edited) | 2,800
The final duel between Vader and Luke will forever live in my head as one of the saddest moments in film.
2 weeks ago | 1,000
Both Obi-Wan and Luke had the high ground in their fights.
2 weeks ago | 863
In terms of choreography, Anakin vs Obi-Wan. But in terms of feeling legitimate tension between the two during their fight, Luke vs Vader. It also helps that Palpatine's taunts only add to the overall tension.
2 weeks ago | 588
The throne room scene in ROTJ is the pinnacle of Star Wars.
2 weeks ago | 378
The story telling in Luke vs Vader ROTJ is absolutely amazing!
2 weeks ago | 189
I like both but Im old school, so i go to Return of the Jedi. The Emperor presence though...
2 weeks ago | 68
One felt like an unwanted, tense struggle between two sides of the same coin. One looked like an overly choreographed CG creation.
1 week ago | 2
Duel of the fates. The Darth Maul, Quai Gon and Obi wan fight was the best light saber duel by a country mile
2 weeks ago | 22
Both have their spiritual themes and symbolism, making them opposite mirrors of each other. The lava and hell-like setting in Revenge of the Sith symbolises not just the battle for Anakin’s soul, but a friendship in flames. Anakin and Obi-wan’s friendship falls apart, and Anakin allows it to happen, despite Obi-Wan’s repeated attempts to reason with him. The novel also ends with Obi-Wan saying, ‘You were my brother, Anakin. I loved you, but I couldn’t save you.’ It’s no wonder Obi-Wan believed Vader to be irredeemable. Luke’s duel with Vader is a battle between a father and son, not just physically, but a battle of wills. Neither side wholly good or evil, and both having moments of holding back. Luke almost falls to the dark side, but redeems Vader. In RoTS, Anakin’s love for his wife led to his fall, but in RoTJ, his love for his son brings him back.
2 weeks ago | 12
The best fight in the entire saga is Luke vs Vader vs The Emperor. So much going on emotionally with the characters. The end of episode 6 imo is the best Star Wars has ever been.
2 weeks ago | 188
The final duel between Luke and Vader will always remain as the most impactful conclusion to a franchise such as Star Wars.
1 week ago | 3
Obi-Wan v Anakin just has it all. Choreography, visual effects, emotional stakes, and most importantly of all, memes.
2 weeks ago | 142
Obi-Wan vs Anakin is all spectacle. Definitely fun to watch, but it doesn’t get emotional till the fight itself is over. Luke vs Vader, however, is character, plot, and theming coming together perfectly.
2 weeks ago | 2
One is Anakin's fall to the dark side, other is his redemption.
2 weeks ago | 3
The Anakin and obi wan fight are definitely the better choreographed and more exciting fight, there is no doubt about it. But, in terms of meaning, and what the like v vader dual represents, Luke and Vader absolutely wins every time. This duel is the final one and the crescendo for all duels that led up to it.
2 weeks ago | 9
That background hymn while Luke takes on Vader is one the best hymns I've heard ever. Both are great for me.
2 weeks ago | 31
“You were my brother Anakin…I loved you.” “I HATE YOOOOU!!!” some of the most haunting cinema
2 weeks ago | 10
The ROTS fight is cool but it is NOTHING on the Empire one, truly the greatest moment in the franchise and one of the best scenes in cinematic history.
2 weeks ago | 2
Vader's Order
Which duel do you like more?
2 weeks ago | [YT] | 16,993