4's winter is more interactions between the gang specially the snowboard trip with the whole horror story making a callback to fuuka in P3 and everything about it is just great, Marie's arc is great and it works really well since despite having the biggest connection with you, everybody in the gang knows her and has spent time with her, you actually cannot finish her social link if naoto hasn't been in one of her filler hangouts in order to meet her so i think I makes sense that everyone wants to save her, it's my favorite one even if I think it's not perfect (Because nothing really happens at all in the midwinter section, only at the snowboard trip does it get interesting)
2 years ago | 11
Dude the third semester goes so hard for no reason. And the music! Omg the music. The final boss was so good (not gonna say their name cause spoilers)
2 years ago | 5
I think the answer is at least just as important to P3 as third Semester is to P5 I would also argue it’s much more important as P5 already had an epilogue while P3 finished abruptly and leaved some things behind. The most interesting to me being what would Aigis do once her reason to live has died in her arms since she obviously didn’t realize it in the ending. Ps. I can’t believe the answer is not considered better than P4 winter which serves no purpose and has one of the most flat character ever.
2 years ago (edited) | 12
The third semester has some of the best writing in the storytelling business period.
2 years ago | 11
It’s a shame they aren’t including the answer in P3R, I would have liked to experience it without resorting to emulation. P4G was kinda hard to do right on the first and second attempt since I keep missing my social links. P5R was amazing with the third semester and Sumi is hands down best girl in my book!
2 years ago (edited) | 3
Never played the answer (and I don’t plan to cuz I ain’t doing another tarturus) but from the clips I’ve seen it really does add missing development for the characters in the story P4G winter arc had a fun ski trip that I found was cool to experience and some of the music was just perfect *chefs kiss*. But that Marie Dungeon was just BADDDD I would never played it again But nothing will ever beat P5R third semester. It has one of biggest themes I’ve ever seen in video games the debate between Freedom or happiness is still something I think about to this day as I’m living my everyday life. Maruki changed my perspective in life man he was one hell of a character. Sumire and Akechi are some of the most complex characters in storytelling and yet beautifully written (Yes i know a lot people who aren’t fans of Sumi’ character but I personally enjoyed every second of it). Seeing all your friends living their best lives in a false reality, questioning between what’s right and wrong and overall really opening your viewpoint on the meaning of life. P5 on its own was a 8/10 experience, the third semester is what made it a 11/10
2 years ago | 3
5's is an amazing addition. 3's has a great story and greatly adds to the message of 3, but is extremely grindy. 4's winter I just felt barely added anything
2 years ago | 6
Just to get to see Akechi's true self more alone is worth it. Him and Joker's Showtime is easily the best of the bunch.)
2 years ago (edited) | 17
P4G's winter gets slandered a lot for not adding story til like the last day but it's more maxing out your SLs and getting 3rd awakenings with your homies before you leave
2 years ago | 3
I'm not too big on Persona 5. Persona 4 on the other hand, it nails the atmosphere of winter so well, the music is fitting for a 'final' act and although the dungeon is a bit gimmicky, it's still decent.
2 years ago | 1
sorry P3R and P4G fans, Persona 5 made me cry and cry with sadness when I saw the lonely joker, kasumi is my favorite girl without a doubt, and the ending...holy shit, very epic and perfect
2 years ago | 3
I haven’t played The Answer but I’ve heard all the problems. Winter in P4 is pretty disappointing, barely anything happens and its hard to plan out your last social link interactions. Many people hate the dungeon’s special mechanics (though I like it). Third semester is the best section of Persona 5’s story and had a chance to dethrone P3 for best final arc. One of the best social links and a fantastic antagonist. There’s hardly any contest here.
2 years ago | 4
I like persona 5 as main game the most. But p4g winter was much better lol.
2 years ago (edited) | 2
To be wholly transparent, I've only played the third semester, but I do intend to play the Answer and Winter when I get around to them.
2 years ago | 2
P5r third sem but for me personally P3's late december to jan 31 is my favourite "arc"
2 years ago | 1
The third semester is my favorite arc in persona 5 now I loved it and the whole concept
2 years ago | 0
Kaito
Favorite out of these?
Discord: discord.gg/kaitos-legion-834577544245411890
2 years ago | [YT] | 108