All-Stars was just really bad. Pahketieu Island had to deal with seasonal rot, but at least it didn't ruin classic characters.
1 year ago | 12
All Stars, there are so, so many problems with it that I couldn’t begin to tell you what’s wrong with it, from terrible derailments, a bad cast, the finale sucking, Mal, and so much more. At least with PI, there were a couple funny new characters like Shawn, Max, and Leonard. All Stars best character is Lightning and he’s second boot.
1 year ago
| 6
I'm gonna be honest with you, All stars was the shit on our childhoods, the characters derailment, terrible main antagonist, not good cast pick, And the finale wasn't even a Gen 1 vs Gen 2 player, This is why I like Pahkitew more, because at least Shawn and Jasmine made the season better, and also Sammy's revenge was awesome.
1 year ago
| 17
If both had completely new casts, Pahkitew would be worse, but since All-Stars derails so many characters we loved, as well as containing some of the worst plays ever done by a contestant, it is still worse in my opinion.
1 year ago | 5
Pahkitew Island is an overhated season tbh, beardo and topher were characters with huge potential and leonard is a personal fav of mine. Instead of ir being bad, i see it more of a season with potential that just got bad execution
1 year ago | 1
@tentacledelixir5511_GYM2Quick
I honestly don't understand how some people consider PI worse than AS.
1 year ago
| 1
All-Stars was Really...REALLY BAD,it Ruined Charecters who Once were Beloved by the Community,The Cast Selection Was Random in a Bad Way,and the Whole "Balloon Incident" is messed up
1 year ago (edited) | 1
Honestly theyre both underrated. Packitew breaks a mold that had been getting pretty stale regarding how TDI focuses on romantic relationships and direct “good guys - bad guys” — something that I think it generally handles worse with the shorter seasons. The characters are definitely more out there but the season’s snappier pace and bits like Sugar believing the dnd weirdo is a REAL wizard make it work Allstars suffers from fans not being able to understand how “character development” doesn’t necessitate “character IMPROVEMENT” and over blow how it “damages” Courtney’s character in comparison to something like season 3 (Courtney squandering her perfect boyfriend and friendship with Gwen and self sabotaging IS A GREAT ENDING TO A STORY ABOUT LETTING OBSESSIVE COMPETITIVENESS AND SELF CENTERED BEHAVIOR RUIN YOUR LIFE!!!!! COURTNEY HAS BEEN ON THIS PATH SINCE SEASON 2!!!!) HOWEVER allstar DOES suffer from a weaker roster — almost entirely due to the complete lack of Packitew characters (where the fuck are Owen and Sugar) as well as committing the cardinal sin of multiple continuity errors in a series built around obsessive continuity. It does also SAVE Scott’s character and make him stand out better as an antagonist
1 year ago | 0
I got to say pakapoo island, all stars at least had some funny moments, pakeypee did to but more rare, and max is best puckyou character
1 year ago | 1
Pahitew bored me most of the time and made me roll my eyes at a few jokes or look away from some gross out humor. All-Stars did the latter two while making me annoyed instead of bored while from the looks of it irreversibly tainted or ruined certain characters that don't seem to be ever coming back in official media AND arguably most importantly was massive waste of potential with what stories could have been told and what interactions we could have gotten compared to Pahitew which has some potential in a few early boots it like to have stayed longer but inarguably not as much as the All-Stars season did. Id rather be mildly entertained half the time and bored the rest then mildly annoyed to downright angered consistently.
1 year ago | 1
Am I really, the only one alright with Mal's arc? I found it intertaining, I'm indecisive anyhow here because I didn't hate either one.
1 year ago | 0
Honestly I'm a huge Shawn fan, but tbh Pahkitew Island shouldn't have even existed. Like there was NO REASON to make a new season with a completely new generation of contestants. Just for that reason I think Pahkitew was worse.
1 year ago | 0
Both seasons suck because the characters and writing sucks. But TDPI was a bunch of new characters, while TDAS ruined several beloved characters that already existed. TDAS definitely takes the cake as the worst offender
1 year ago (edited) | 0
Lightro_Storm
What season of Total Drama was the worst? (between these two)
1 year ago | [YT] | 54