I like the old one. I also like to think creators who follow their own preferences for their channels are happier in the long run than those who focus on engagement and clickability. So whichever one you like better or you feel resonates with your core community better :)
1 month ago | 244
The old one is a lot cleaner, but the new one conveys the idea better imo
1 month ago | 375
The old style is pure nostalgia for us veterans but the new style gives it some "omph" and pleasant face lift.
1 month ago (edited) | 110
Tbh i love your old style thumbnials, its what make xisumavoud....xisumavoid (its just iconic and i love that)
1 month ago | 55
I saw the same video but with different thumbnails a few hours ago, and clicked on it when it had the old thumbnail because I thought it was more informative. While the new one grabbed my attention, I saw the sheep wool parity change from the old thumbnail and that made me interested enough to watch it. Long story short, I think the old one is better cause it shows all of the new texture/data packs so there’s more of a chance for someone to see something that interests them.
1 month ago | 12
i think the new one is a bit too busy. when i first saw the thumbnail i assumed it was a new SMP series or something
1 month ago | 16
I like the old style a lot better, the new style is a little chaotic.
1 month ago | 4
I saw both, the old one got my click because it made me understand that it was about the resource pack, not just the changes to vanilla made by the new update which I had seen in other videos
1 month ago | 4
i like the old style better because i can instantly tell what kind of video it is and whether or not it’s worth me clicking on
1 month ago | 22
The new one has "every YouTube thumbnail nowadays" syndrome, in my opinion. If I didn't notice you were the poster of the video, I would just tune it out. The old style feels less noisy. To be fair, I'm also 30, so that might influence my opinion compared to a younger audience lol
1 month ago | 5
Old style is far more comprehensive and maintains a stronger sense of visual identity tying it back to your other videos and your brand imo.
1 month ago | 3
i like the old because im used to the old format as it clearly identifies the video as an update video instead of your other content.
1 month ago | 3
With the old one it's immediately clear that's it's your channel. The new one is more generic.
1 month ago | 9
i prefer the banner on the old style, because i didn’t even realize it was a vanilla tweaks video at first. the new logo is too similar to minecraft my brain just ignored it otherwise the new style is better though
1 month ago | 3
I prefer the old one, crisp and clean and screams Xisuma update video at first glance. The new is ok, fresh but busy and detracts from that first glance recognition. Imo it's one of those If it isn't broken why change/fix it? situations, the old look is iconic as its been a thing for so long, it conveys the message in an Xisuma Minecrafty way, so in my opinion nothing needs changing unless it's actually a problem and evolution needs to happen, but I don't really think that's the case.
1 month ago | 9
I would prefer a mix of the two maybe? Newer graphics/style but with the old banner text
1 month ago | 3
xisumavoid
There is a new video out on the channel. My question is, what thumbnail do you prefer?
1 month ago | [YT] | 1,591