I feel the same when I listen to his music… I can hear his sadness and it makes me sad, even though it’s so beautiful.
2 years ago
| 3
Don't be hard on yourself. It ok to miss him and you can feel happy listening to his voice. I too miss him so much❤
2 years ago
| 9
It made me cry in a good way. I felt the same as you. It was like a gift. I have only just over the last 2 years been able to slowly listen to Jjong's solo music again...A part of that is actually because of YT...watching people hear our Jonghyun's voice and music for the first time and being in awe at his talent and skill... laughing at his OTT moments and hearing his insight and empathy for others..These people that are here still loving and valuing him in retrospect and even sharing the grief of loss ...it's helped me through a lot. I still can't listen to Before Our Spring though or Let Me Out and don't know if I ever will. I'm sorry if others felt uncomfortable with it.. their feelings are of course just as valid ...but to me it was a precious gift, a little moment to say hi Jonghyunie.❤️❤️
2 years ago (edited)
| 3
Dont be hard on yourself. I totally understand were you are coming from. Listen and do whatever makes you happy. I understand both sides honestly. But no need to apologize for something that made you happy ❤️
2 years ago (edited)
| 5
You do you. Don’t listen to people who are hard on you, if possible. You are a bright star 🌟
2 years ago
| 16
PLEASE DO WHATEVER that makes u happy... I even imagine him singing with them in every song, especially in their harmonies.. I feel him.
2 years ago
| 0
This is your channel! Be yourself and express your missing feeling for Jonghyun on your own unique way. We can not please everyone. If other shawols can't handle the AI stuff, they are wise enough to ignore it. Don't be hard on yourself. I miss Jonghyun too and want to see a Hologram of Jonghyun in the future concerts where we can see Jjong singing live with the members. I know not all blingers and shawols can accept it, but we all have our own ways to express our longing for Jjong. Respect everybody's way is important.
2 years ago (edited)
| 13
It was so nice to see and hear the video. Thank you for sharing. I remember when Natalie Cole and others created a video with her father, Nat King Cole, who had passed. They've done it with other vocalists, and I didn't hear any backlash, maybe due to the family's participation or copyrights, etc. But I guess because people are feeling more sophisticated and aware today, that is now a thing. Thank you for sharing as openly as you do. Others may have their own opinions and reactions, but it can be seen as more of a tribute than anything else. I was listening to something where the members were talking about Jonghyun. My friend was listening and said "oh It's nice they talk so comfortably about him." Of course, they are comfortable talking about Jonghyun because he is such an integral part of the group, as we have witnessed throughout this time in all of their songs, activities, and interactions. I deeply appreciate the love and efforts you contribute on the regular 💜
2 years ago (edited)
| 0
This is your way of keeping him here with all of us. I enjoyed what you did. An would like to hear more of it, even if it is AI. In this case, for me. It is the closest thing to have. To hear his vocals in newer 5HINee music, and experience what he would have sounded like in a particular song. We keep Jjong's music alive by listening to it. Not just his solo or other works with his team. But with this type of AI an creating. I think this is a positive all the way around. KEEP DOING what you do. Do not let the negativity pull you down. Jjong would have been happy i believe to know that you did this for him an other's. <3 Jjong was/is such a wonderful light to all.
2 years ago | 0
I get you. it´s a shared feeling, that missing. I wish i could see him , listen to him for a few seconds... that longing is with me every day. You´re not allone
2 years ago
| 1
Don't worry. I understand your feelings, sometimes people need it to be able to return to those happy memories. I understand the feelings of people who don't like artificial intelligence. But I see advantages in artificial intelligence and opportunities to use it in good things. Artificial intelligence was created by people in order to get better, but unfortunately it is considered bad, because there are people who use it for bad things. I would like to save good memories, the creativity of artists with the help of artificial intelligence, in the future other people could see this creativity.
2 years ago
| 6
It’s okay to continue listening to Jonghyun beautiful singing Voice please don’t listen and just ignore the ridiculous toxicity still happening on YouTube and Social Media most importantly continue to love support Jonghyun and shinee
2 years ago
| 2
You didn’t do anything wrong. I understand it’s a touchy subject for a lot of people, but it’s not like you tried to deceive people but it was really him. Thanks for all you do!
2 years ago
| 2
i understand you may get comfort from it but i personally find it disrespectful to him
2 years ago | 6
I wasn't able to listen to it while it was still uploaded. But who am i kidding? i wouldn't be able to click that at all, I'm still unable to listen to his voice fully until now unless it's something that's rookie shinee/pre-3rd gen shinee 💛
2 years ago | 0
I hope u understand why people r against sharing it but don't feel guilty for listening to it,if u miss him too much you can go listen to the audio personally, don't overthink it,it was a simple mistake . It's ur channel yes but it also has big public reach, u need to take people's opinion in consideration too,sry if it sucks but it is what it is. I'm that his voice brought u comfort and now don't overthink,what happened is in past
2 years ago | 1
What happened?! Don't understand but just ignore anyone! Do what makes you happy and comfortable it's ur channel not anyone's!! And I am so happy you were able to listen to his voice 💚🥰I came through this do I know just wait abit more with time u will be able to listen to his beautiful voice again and enjoy it I am sure^^ have a nice day dear and be well pls & everyone
2 years ago | 0
Do whatever makes you happy. Some Shawols are gatekeeping. Nobody owns him to tell others what to do. Treating artists as property is the most destructive attitude and the reason artists cannot have control of their own lives. Many fans edit images, including painting and drawing idols, they also invent stories. This is no different in my opinion.
2 years ago
| 0
SHINE days
All right guys, I deleted the video which has his voice using AI.
Actually, I still can’t really listen to his old songs. Because they contain his sadness and feelings that I missed at the time.
But the new song with his voice restored by AI, I could hear it even though it make me to burst into tears. It was possible because I knew that the voice wasn't really his. I felt happy for a moment, even if it was fake, in the midst of nostalgia, sadness, and joy. Isn't that enough?
It's not really his voice, but I was finally able to meet his voice, and I was able to meet him once again. I mean, it was a pleasure for me.
There are some negatives that AI has, but if it allows someone who misses someone deeply to smile for a moment, would that be such a sin?
I'm sorry if I made you uncomfortable. But don't be so hard on me. I was happy for a moment, but that doesn't mean I don't respect him. I just miss it. That voice that I can't hear anymore...
2 years ago | [YT] | 340