I’m willing to listen to the story, but I would also like to know why some people think she’s innocent and why some people think she’s guilty. Too many times in cases like this, we only get the version of the people that think the convict is innocent. I want to hear both sides equally if you’re going to present this case.
3 weeks ago
| 15
If it's Darley Routier she is guilty. I lived 15 mins from where it happened at the time. It was non stop news coverage for a year. It is heinous what she did to those babies.
3 weeks ago
| 15
Dear Vince, my first thought was this topic is a departure for your channel, focusing on a more contemprary case. My second thought was you seem to have doubts about whether you should tell this story. I know you trust your community, but I think you should trust yourself.
3 weeks ago
| 13
If it’s about Darlie Routier, I wouldn’t support it. She’s 100% guilty and everything her defense brings up has been debunked. There’s a lot of misinformation in her case that gets repeated as fact. If it’s about anyone else, I’d support it if it was balanced and neutral in terms of the evidence against her and the doubts about her guilt.
3 weeks ago
| 6
I know the story and she’s definitely guilty. Those poor boys. Her husband knows it too, he’s just too lame to go against her! She is the epitome of a narcissist 👎
3 weeks ago | 4
I'm no in the States, so I'm a neutral. When children are involved, there's emotion by default. I think if you handle it by giving both sides of the story, I'm sure you'll do another great job.
3 weeks ago | 3
I'd be interested to hear & see the story Vince..thanks Andy across the pond in the UK
3 weeks ago
| 2
I would like to see this story on Odd Mystery Channel.
3 weeks ago | 8
Ultimately, I trust your instincts about what fits with your shows. I also believe that you having a passion for each case you cover is best for your show. You put a great deal of work into these presentations, and if you don't feel that passion for each story, you will burn yourself out. Much also depends on who approached you to cover this case and what this person's interest in the case is. Plenty of people in the general public become fixated on a case and will push every creator to cover their pet case. Letting them influence you too much can be a path to disaster. On the other hand, I understand being influenced by relatives of people involved in the cases. Relieving their pain makes sense. If her husband truly believes that she is innocent, I'm inclined to have doubt. Obviously, solving an important case or raising important points in a case is always of interest to us.
3 weeks ago | 2
There seems to be a current trend of shows attempting to cast doubt about the evidence of people who were convicted of the most heinous of crimes. It seems over time as it becomes harder for these shows to find the "next big case" of someone who was wrongfully convicted, that they become desperate & hence a lot of these shows start using cases where there seems to be little doubt of the persons guilt. Tacky.
3 weeks ago | 4
Absolutely! This is an 'arm chair' detective who's done it..
3 weeks ago
| 1
Is it Darlie? I searched & several cases fit the bill! If its her, I never felt she was guilty & the police just focused on her. Yes, please cover.
3 weeks ago | 5
I'd be curious to hear the story and what odd tidbits are causing doubts of her guilt.
3 weeks ago (edited) | 2
Yes, please cover the case and lay out all the evidence.
3 weeks ago | 3
If it's darlie routier then I would personally listen. I have spent the last 2 years studying and personally looking into the case, and I have a little bit of doubt about her quilt, but that's just my opinion.
2 weeks ago | 1
I personally would like to hear about it, and I am always an advocate for people who do things because they have been through intense trauma and do not need to be put in jail, let alone on death row
3 weeks ago | 3
Odd Mysteries - Stories
I always trust the community to give honest helpful feedback. I need your help with this one, please.
I was recently approached to do a story about someone who was convicted of murdering her children and is currently on death row. (I'm sure if you want to you can find the full story yourself)
IMO there is a small amount of doubt about her guilt and even one of her jurors has since said that they believe there is enough doubt that she should not be on death row. Her husband and family believe in her innocence.
Here's my question. Do you my trusted viewers believe that this is a story that should be brought to the channel? Thank you for taking the time to provide your comments and feedback. Vince
3 weeks ago | [YT] | 93