COINVERSATIONS
Coinversations is a South African numismatic podcast and video series dedicated to the stories behind coins, banknotes, medals, bullion, auctions, and collecting.
From rare South African coins and ZAR history to modern bullion, grading, scams, valuations, and the future of collecting, this channel exists to make numismatics more accessible, exciting, and trusted.
Coinversations is proudly connected to the South African Coin Collectors Club and aims to grow the next generation of collectors by sharing knowledge, preserving history, and building a stronger collecting community.
Subscribe for coin stories, collecting tips, auction conversations, educational episodes, and the history hidden in your pocket.
Where coins tell stories.
COINVERSATIONS
Proof vs Mint State: an important numismatic lesson
In South African numismatics, one of the most common misunderstandings is assuming that Proof automatically means rarer or more valuable than Mint State.
That is not always the case.
Mint State, or MS, refers to a coin struck for normal circulation, but which has survived in uncirculated condition.
Proof, or PF, refers to a coin specially struck for collectors, usually with prepared dies, sharper detail, and a more refined finish.
The real value difference depends on the specific coin, the year, the mintage figures, the grade, survival rate, and collector demand.
Sometimes the Proof issue is the scarcer and more valuable coin.
Sometimes the Mint State example is harder to find in high grade, and can be more valuable than the Proof.
For collectors, this is why research matters.
A good exercise is to open the digital Brian Hern catalogue and look for examples where the Mint State price is higher than the Proof price.
Then ask why:
Was the circulation strike heavily used?
Did very few survive in high grade?
Is there stronger demand for the Mint State example?
Or is the Proof version more available than expected?
This is why numismatic value is never just about metal content. It is about history, condition, rarity, grade, and market demand.
South African coins tell our history, but they also teach us how markets work.
#Numismatics #SouthAfricanCoins #CoinCollecting #RareCoins #SilverCoins
1 week ago | [YT] | 4
View 0 replies
COINVERSATIONS
Same year. Same type. Very different value.
Both of these coins are 1946 South African 2½ Shillings, and 1946 is a key date year with a very low mintage. That is why even the raw example can still attract collector interest, and a space-filler piece could realistically trade around the R500 level depending on the collector and the market.
So why is there still such a big gap between these two?
Because the date is only part of the story.
The raw coin is a circulated example with noticeable wear. The slabbed coin, on the other hand, is a 1946 proof graded PF64 by SANGS. Proof coins were specially made for collectors using polished dies and blanks, with far greater attention to detail and finish than normal circulation pieces. Only 150 proof examples were struck for 1946.
That is why one coin can be a collector placeholder, while the other sits in a completely different value category at around R6,000 in Hern’s catalogue.
This is one of the clearest examples of why grading, preservation, and strike type matter in numismatics.
Two coins may share the same date, but they do not always share the same rarity, quality, or value.
#JWHCoins #CoinGrading #SouthAfricanCoins #Numismatics #SANGS
1 month ago | [YT] | 3
View 0 replies
COINVERSATIONS
THIS IS A MUST WATCH FOR SOUTH AFRICANS!
8 months ago | [YT] | 3
View 0 replies